lichess.org
Donate

Why Russia will loose

The war won't be decided on either side running out of manpower. Russia took like 200K casualties by now, meaning both dead and wounded. But they can potentially loose millions.

But they also lost a lot of weapon systems. They just hit more than 4K tanks and 4K artillery both.

They were estimated to have 10K tanks before the war. That's also with tanks from almost wwII and stuff that has been stored outside for decades so barely useless. Some of the old junk is usefull though. An outdated shell still explodes and kills people if you get hit.

Anyway, when you loose 4K tanks in 14 months or fighting, you're going to have a problem when you hit 10K tanks lost - in like two years from now. The same goes for artillery and so on.

So quite simply, in a couple of years Russia's stock will be depleted. There's already signs this is happening, because they're taking like 60 years old tanks out of storage.

Then it comes down to "can Russia produce enugh new tanks to beat Ukraine on equiptment".

Which is the same as asking "can Russia with 140 milion population outproduce the countries with more than one BILLION combined population that is giving stuff to Ukraine." (And that on top of having like 900 million more people also are way more developed economically.)

Quite obviously, they cannot do that. It's simply impossible for Russia to win.

The war ends when Russia runs so low on military gear like tanks, helicopters, artillery, that they can't even control the country.

It will take a couple of years probably.
In today's news, it was reported that the Wagner Team, a group of mercenaries, up to recently working for Russia, has proceeded to move toward the capitol, wreaking havoc. Their leader has said he will stop the advance but he has not offered any type of draw. This hurts Russia both offensively (Wagner had been an effective force against Russia), and defensively (apparently there is not a strong enough reserve and Russia may have to bring troops from Ukraine back to Russia). Putin may be putting himself in a noose.
@walnutparkk said in #3:
> In today's news, it was reported that the Wagner Team, a group of mercenaries, up to recently working for Russia, has proceeded to move toward the capitol, wreaking havoc. Their leader has said he will stop the advance but he has not offered any type of draw. This hurts Russia both offensively (Wagner had been an effective force against Russia), and defensively (apparently there is not a strong enough reserve and Russia may have to bring troops from Ukraine back to Russia). Putin may be putting himself in a noose.
Perhaps you're a little late with the news. Wagner started moving on June 23 late in the evening. They were moving towards Moscow all day yesterday but then turned around and went back to their place after the Belarus president talked to them
@walnutparkk said in #3:
> In today's news, it was reported that the Wagner Team, a group of mercenaries, up to recently working for Russia, has proceeded to move toward the capitol, wreaking havoc. Their leader has said he will stop the advance but he has not offered any type of draw. This hurts Russia both offensively (Wagner had been an effective force against Russia), and defensively (apparently there is not a strong enough reserve and Russia may have to bring troops from Ukraine back to Russia). Putin may be putting himself in a noose.

That was yesterday - and the Wagner's gave up their whatever it is and Prigozhin, the leader, agreed to move to Belarus.

I don't think the Wagner thing means much at all in the big picture. Russia has enough people, and in the end 10K soldiers are 10K soliders, if they're called normal soldiers or Wagners or whatever.

So I'm still thinking what matters is the material - especially tanks and artillery systems.
@Chessmates4ever said in #2:
> This last line completely broke me.

This unless Ukraine gets a lot faster at blowing up stuff or Russia loose large numbers of material in routs (like last fall after the Izyum offensive). That would be great but I don't really think it will happen.

Best case to me is Ukraine has a breakthrough in the offense now, but even then Russia IMO will retreat to some corner of east Ukraine, maybe the regions they defended since 2014 and then the rest of the fighting will happen there in a smaller space.
Such is the thoughts of the lichess strategist. I once read Sun Tzu's "The art of kicking butt" or whatever it is called.
If by lose you mean quit then yes, of course. But putin will stay in power until he dies, and Ukraine wont ever invade Russia.
Yes, we all know that Russia is going to lose! The only question is when.
Whatever is going to happen in the war, it's like a roll of a die.
You can't predict what could happen in a stalemate.

This topic has been archived and can no longer be replied to.